What should I do about a clicking PS5 controller after replacing analog sticks, how to fix?

Facing the same issue, I discovered that the problem lay with the internal springs.

1. Reopen the Controller: Carefully unscrew and open the controller.
2. Inspect Internal Springs: Check the small tension springs related to the analog sticks.
3. Adjust or Replace Springs: If the springs are misaligned or damaged, adjust them or replace them if you have spares.
4. Add Padding: Consider adding thin padding around the springs to reduce excessive movement.
5. Lubricate Moving Parts: Apply a small amount of suitable lubricant to the moving parts.
6. Reassemble and Test: Securely reassemble the controller and test it out.

This approach significantly minimized the clicking noise for me.

For a more detailed troubleshooting procedure, follow these steps:

1. Open the Controller: Carefully remove the screws using a Phillips screwdriver and open the controller casing using a plastic prying tool.
2. Inspect the Analog Sticks: Ensure the sticks move freely and without obstruction. Check the surrounding wires and plastic components for any misalignment.
3. Reposition Loose Parts: Realign any components that might have moved during the replacement, including springs and connectors.
4. Apply Lubricant: Use a small amount of plastic-safe lubricant at the base of the analog sticks if friction is causing the clicking noise.
5. Reassemble and Test: Put the controller back together and test its functionality before closing it completely.

These steps should address any misalignment or internal friction causing the clicking sound.

I had a similar issue, and it drove me crazy for days. Here’s the process I followed that eventually solved it:

• Disassemble the controller again. Pay attention to the internal components, especially around the analog sticks.
• Examine the housing. Ensure that no plastic parts are misaligned or interfering with one another.
• Fasten all internal screws securely, but avoid overtightening.
• Test the controller with the back cover off. I found that one of the connecting springs was misplaced, causing the click.
• After correcting the spring position and reassembling, my controller was back to normal.

If you’re like me, you might find that these steps solve your issue:

1. Disassemble the Controller: Use a precision screwdriver set to carefully take apart your controller.
2. Review Internal Fit: Check that the replacement analog sticks fit properly and all parts align correctly. File down any rough edges if necessary.
3. Re-seat Connections: Ensure each ribbon cable and connector is properly seated to secure the internal connections.
4. Apply Electrical Tape: Wrap a strip of electrical tape around the base of the analog stick module to stabilize any loose fits.
5. Test Before Fully Closing: Before closing the controller, move the analog sticks in all directions to check for the noise.
6. Reassemble: Once confirmed that the clicking is gone, reassemble the controller.

Following these steps eliminated the clicking noise for me, allowing for a smooth gaming experience again.

I had this exact problem and found that the issue was primarily with the way the replacement analog sticks were fitted. Here’s a quick checklist that solved my problem:

1. Re-check and ensure that all parts are screwed in tightly but not too tight to avoid additional stress on the plastic components.
2. Inspect the new analog sticks carefully; sometimes tiny manufacturing defects can cause noise.
3. Apply a small drop of silicon-based lubricant at the base of the analog sticks to reduce friction.

These steps fixed the clicking noise in my controller almost instantly.